£0.00 0

Basket

No products in the basket.

Air source heat pump outdoor unit installed beside the brick wall of a house

Heat Pump vs Gas Boiler: An Installer’s Straight Comparison for Yorkshire Homes

A heat pump is usually the better choice for a home that holds its heat, has room for a hot water cylinder and an outdoor unit, and qualifies for the Boiler Upgrade Scheme grant. A modern gas boiler is often the pragmatic choice for now if the house loses heat quickly, there is nowhere to put a cylinder, or the old boiler has failed and you need heating back this week. The deciding factors are the house itself, the upfront cost after the grant, and what each system will cost you to run.

We fit both. U&I Renewables is MCS certified for heat pumps and Gas Safe registered for boilers, so when we weigh up heat pump vs gas boiler for your home, the survey decides which one goes on the quote. Our own gas boilers page puts it plainly: sometimes a heat pump isn’t the right move yet. This guide sets out how our engineers make that call on a real Yorkshire house.

Heat pump vs gas boiler at a glance

The two systems heat your home in different ways, and most of the practical differences follow from that.

  • How it makes heat. A gas boiler burns gas, and the modern condensing boilers we fit run at up to 94% efficiency. An air source heat pump uses electricity to move heat from the outside air into your heating water, and a well-designed system delivers several units of heat for every unit of electricity it uses.
  • Upfront cost. A boiler swap is the smaller outlay. A heat pump costs more to fit, and the Boiler Upgrade Scheme takes up to £7,500 off that cost.
  • Running cost. This depends on how efficiently the heat pump is designed to run and on the gap between electricity and gas prices. More on that below.
  • Hot water. A combi boiler heats water on demand. A heat pump stores hot water in a cylinder.
  • Space. A combi fits in a kitchen cupboard. A heat pump needs an outdoor unit against a wall or on a base, plus a cylinder indoors.
  • How it feels. A boiler heats radiators quickly to a high temperature. A heat pump runs at a lower temperature for longer, which gives steadier warmth through the day.
  • Servicing. Both should be serviced every year, and our service plans cover either one.

Upfront cost after the Boiler Upgrade Scheme

The fair way to compare upfront cost is a heat pump quote with the grant already taken off, set against a like-for-like boiler quote for the same house. Comparing a heat pump’s full price with a boiler swap tells you very little.

The Boiler Upgrade Scheme gives £7,500 towards an air source heat pump fitted by an MCS certified installer. We check your eligibility, design the system and handle the whole grant application, so the money comes straight off your quote rather than arriving as a refund later. With the grant taken off, our air source heat pump installations typically come to around £2,000 to £3,000. You can read the scheme rules on gov.uk and our own summary on the air source heat pump grants page.

When you compare quotes, check what each one includes. A complete heat pump quote should cover the outdoor unit, the cylinder, any radiators that need upgrading, controls, electrical work and commissioning. A boiler quote should cover the flue, controls, a system flush and the manufacturer warranty, which on the boilers we fit runs up to 10 years. For installation price ranges and what moves a house up or down them, see our air source heat pump costs breakdown.

Running costs: what the comparison depends on

Whether a heat pump costs less to run than a gas boiler comes down to one sum: how many units of heat the heat pump gets from each unit of electricity, set against how much more a unit of electricity costs than a unit of gas.

Electricity costs several times more per unit than gas. A modern condensing boiler turns almost all of its gas into heat. A heat pump has to deliver enough heat per unit of electricity to close that price gap before it saves you anything, and how far it goes past that point decides your bills. Current unit rates are set by the Ofgem energy price cap, and the Energy Saving Trust publishes independent guidance on heat pump performance.

Three things push a heat pump’s efficiency up:

  • A low flow temperature. The cooler the water the heat pump sends to your radiators, the more efficiently it runs. That is only possible when the radiators are large enough to keep each room warm at that temperature.
  • Correct sizing. A system designed from a room-by-room heat loss calculation runs steadily. An oversized one cycles on and off and wastes energy.
  • The right tariff. Heat pump and time-of-use electricity tariffs can lower the price you pay per unit, especially if you also have solar PV or a battery.

One more saving is easy to miss. If the heat pump replaces gas entirely and you have no other gas appliances, you can stop paying the gas standing charge.

Is your house suited to a heat pump?

Suitability is about the building, and Yorkshire’s housing covers the full range, from solid-wall stone terraces to cavity-wall semis and modern estate homes. These are the points our survey checks.

How well it holds heat

A heat pump works best in a home with loft insulation, filled cavity walls where there are cavities, and reasonable glazing. Older solid-wall houses can still suit a heat pump, but the heat loss calculation will ask for a larger system and larger radiators, and that shows up in the quote.

Your radiators and pipework

Because a heat pump runs cooler than a boiler, each room needs enough radiator surface to stay warm at that lower temperature. Many existing radiators are fine. Undersized ones, often single-panel radiators in rooms with high heat loss, are swapped for larger double or triple panel models. We also check that the pipework can carry the flow the heat pump needs.

Space for a cylinder and an outdoor unit

If you have a combi boiler, a heat pump means finding room for a hot water cylinder, typically in an old airing cupboard, a utility room or a loft. Outside, the unit needs a spot on a wall or a base with clear airflow. Most homes in England can fit one under permitted development, with extra rules for listed buildings and conservation areas. We also fit water cylinders, so the cylinder is part of the same job.

Your electrics

A heat pump adds a significant electrical load. We check your incoming supply and consumer unit on the survey, and the local network operator is told about the installation.

When a modern gas boiler is the pragmatic choice

A new condensing boiler with good controls is a sound decision in several situations, and we recommend one whenever the survey points that way.

  • The boiler has failed and you need heat now. A heat pump needs a survey, a system design and a grant application before it goes in. A boiler replacement is the quicker route to a warm house.
  • The house loses heat fast and fabric work is planned. Insulating first and revisiting a heat pump later gives you a smaller, cheaper system when the time comes.
  • There is no room for a cylinder or an outdoor unit. Some flats and small terraces have neither, and a combi is the practical fit.
  • The cost gap after the grant is too large for now. A boiler keeps you warm and efficient while you plan the next step.

Hybrid systems, which pair a heat pump with a gas boiler, are another option for some homes. For more on replacement boilers, see our gas boiler installation page.

When a heat pump is the right move

A heat pump is the stronger choice when your boiler is ageing but still working, which gives you time to survey, design and apply for the grant without pressure. It also suits homes that are already reasonably insulated, have or can make room for a cylinder, and have radiators that are well sized or easy to upgrade.

It pairs well with solar panels, because daytime generation can run the heat pump and heat your hot water. And if you plan to stay in the house for years, the longer you run an efficient system, the more the upfront difference is worth it. Our air source heat pump installation page explains how we design and fit each system.

How we decide on your house

Because we fit both, the recommendation follows the house. Our survey is a room-by-room heat loss assessment, a check of your radiators, pipework, cylinder space and electrics, and a conversation about how you use your heating. If the numbers point to a heat pump, we design it to MCS standards and handle the grant. If they point to a boiler, our Gas Safe engineers fit it.

U&I has been trading for more than 17 years from our base in Doncaster. We started as a heating servicing and maintenance specialist before moving into renewables, and our engineers are directly employed, so the people who install your system are the same people who service it afterwards. Our stated approach is simple: “We’ll even recommend competitors if it’s in your best interest.” You can read more about us here.

Common questions

Is a heat pump better than a gas boiler?

For a home that holds its heat and has space for a cylinder, a well-designed heat pump is the better long-term system, with lower carbon emissions, steady warmth and a grant towards the cost. For a house with high heat loss, no room for a cylinder or an urgent breakdown, a modern condensing boiler is often the better choice for now. A survey of the house settles it.

Is a heat pump cheaper to run than a gas boiler?

It can be, and the margin depends on two things: how efficiently the heat pump is designed to run, and the gap between electricity and gas prices at the time. A system sized from a proper heat loss survey, running at a low flow temperature on a suitable electricity tariff, gives you the best chance of beating gas.

Will a heat pump work with my existing radiators?

Often, yes. Heat pumps run at lower water temperatures than boilers, so each room needs enough radiator surface to stay warm at that lower temperature. The heat loss survey checks every room, and the quote shows exactly which radiators, if any, need upgrading.

I have a combi boiler. Can I still have a heat pump?

Yes. A heat pump heats your water through a cylinder rather than on demand, so moving from a combi means finding space for one, often in an old airing cupboard, a utility room or a loft. We fit and service cylinders as well as heat pumps, so this is part of the same job.

Do heat pumps work in Yorkshire winters?

Yes. Air source heat pumps take heat from outside air even below freezing, and they are built to run through a British winter. Efficiency falls as the air gets colder, which is why the system is sized for the coldest days your area typically sees rather than an average day.

My boiler has broken. Should I replace it with a heat pump?

If you need heating back quickly, a new gas boiler is usually the faster fix, because a heat pump needs a survey, a system design and a grant application before installation. If the old boiler can be repaired to keep you going, that buys time to plan a heat pump properly. Call us and we will talk through both options for your house.

Get a straight recommendation for your home

Book a free, no-obligation survey and we will tell you straight whether a heat pump or a new boiler suits your house, with the grant taken off where it applies. Already been quoted? Send it over and we’ll tell you whether it’s a good price. Request your survey online or call us on 01302 879038.

Categories:
Last update: